SAVE UP TO $180
Offer valid on select sets of 4 tires
Mail in form to save up to $180
Free rotation included
Road hazard available
Columbus (2385 Silver dr), OH
Mavis Discount Tire in Bay Shore (Montauk Hwy), NY
300 West Main St., Bay Shore (Montauk hwy), NY 11706Directions
We're Closed
Depend On Us To Keep You Moving
Services available at this store
- Find The Right Tires
Browse hundreds of tires to find the right fit for your needs.
- Schedule Expert Service
We'll diagnose and perform any necessary service on your vehicle.
- Book a Consultation
Not sure what your vehicle needs? No problem we'll look it over and advise you on next steps.
Tire Purchase
Wheel Alignment
Tire Repair
Tire Rotation
Tire Balance Check
TPMS Sensor
Store Details
Amenities
Water Dispenser
Accessible Restroom
Free Wifi
TV
Air Conditioning
Workstations
Watch-While-You-Wait-Window
Free Tire Air Machine
Hours
Monday
8:00am - 6:00pm
Tuesday
8:00am - 6:00pm
Wednesday
8:00am - 6:00pm
Thursday
8:00am - 8:30pm
Friday
8:00am - 6:00pm
Saturday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Sunday
9:00am - 5:00pm
On Mantauk Highway (Main Street), across from the Forum Diner, 1/4 mile west of 5th Avenue
Featured Rebates
- Learn More
Valid from 4/1/25 - 5/31/25
SAVE UP TO $100
Offer valid on select sets of 4 tires
Mail-in form to save up to $100
Free rotation included
Road hazard available
Learn MoreValid from 4/1/25 - 5/31/25
PASSENGER TIRES STARTING AT $64.99
Free Rotation Included
Great All Season Traction
60-Day Ride Guarantee
SUV TIRES STARTING AT $99.99
40K+ Mileage Warranty
Great Wet Weather Traction
Free Rotation Included
5,845 Store Reviews
Reviews are taken from customer satisfaction surveys and Google reviews.
1 - 10 of 5,845 Reviews
1 day ago
My experience at Mavis on Main Street, Bay Shore was pleasant and the Service was exceptional! Both Jay and Alex were very knowledgable and took the time to thoroughly answer my questions and explain details. Thank you Jay and Alex for your professionalism and expertise!
2 days ago
These guys rock! Prompt, friendly service- always ready to help you out in an emergency tire replacement situation!
3 days ago
Friendly, quick, excellent service with a smile. They did everything they could to help. Thank you again!!
7 days ago
Excellent and quick service. Very professional. 5 stars
12 days ago
Good
13 days ago
Very professional. Showed up and got us in very quickly. New tires on car within 25 minutes
13 days ago
Jay was great friendly professional and helpful the whole way through!
16 days ago
Accommodating as a walk in customer for balancing tires.
17 days ago
Came in for oil change was finished in about 10 minutes
19 days ago
Update they did make good on my issue. I would say it was resolved however, the experience has effected whether I will use them again. Therefore, I am not changing my star rating.
Browse Popular Tire Brands:
Nearby Stores
Store FinderBay Shore NY
1.8 miles away
1742 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore (Sunrise hwy), NY 11706
East Islip NY
4.2 miles away
201 East Main St., East Islip, NY 11730
Deer Park NY
4.3 miles away
384 Commack Rd., Deer Park (Commack rd), NY 11729
Deer Park NY
5.2 miles away
1965 Deer Park Ave., Deer Park (Deer Pk ave), NY 11729
Lindenhurst NY
5.6 miles away
301 East Montauk Highway, Lindenhurst (Montauk hwy), NY 11757
Tires and Brakes in Bay Shore, NY
Your local Mavis store is proud to serve the communities of Brightwaters, and West Islip with their vehicle maintenance and repair needs. Services include Brake Repair, Wheel Alignments, Tire Repair, Tire Rotation, Oil Changes, State Inspections, and more. In addition to service and repair needs, Mavis also offers deals on leading brands including Bridgestone, Continental, Dunlop, Firestone, Goodyear, and Michelin.